Keys to Understanding the Relationship Between Primary Care and Hospital Revenue
A Summary of Marc Halley’s New Book: The Primary Care-Market Share Connection: How Hospitals Achieve Competitive Advantage, by Marc Halley, Chicago, Health Administration Press, 2007, www.ache.org/hapShareOffer
Points to remember include:
- The true measure of market share is the number of primary care physicians (PCPs) who refer patients to a hospital and its affiliated specialty physicians.
- Relationship management is key to attaining sustainable competitive advantage
- Sustainable competitive advantage requires that successful organizations remember their fundamental purpose: to create and keep customers, which comes down to the right targets, right processes, and the right execution daily
Summary:
p.6 Hospital CEOs need to focus on PCPs who create loyal groups of customers for hospital and its specialists by building long-term relationships with their patients
p.19 Most patients have difficult time recognizing clinical competence and quality; providing great clinical care is necessary but not sufficient in today’s consumer-driven environment, where convenience, accessibility, and responsiveness matter; moments of truth involve key episodes where patients come into contact with healthcare professionals and form lasting impressions (p.45)
p. 21-2 Patients generally do not self-refer to specialists and depend on medical professionals to refer them to specialists; complexity of care perpetuates this dependence; PCP referrals to specialists are usually based on past experiences, friendships, and recommendations from other PCPs in their practice rather than personal witness to specialist’s skill
p. 25-27 In competitive markets, providers sustain competitive advantage by making patients the center of their universe; retail readiness requires: positive word-of-mouth, knowledge of patients’ needs, wants, and priorities, convenience, providing high-quality information, setting expectations, customer service training, measuring the customer experience, and viewing complaints as opportunities to improve quality and service (see Appendix A: retail readiness questionnaire)
p. 31-3 Primary care = market share, which must be understood by all members of the demand chain; loftiest mission statement is irrelevant unless organization is able to find and keep patients to care for
p.62-9 very few organizations can prove that they have the best physicians; to retain referral base, specialists need to demonstrate convenient access and respect by acknowledging referral, engaging the PCP in treatment decisions, sharing knowledge and expertise, and returning patient to PCP for f/u care
p.93-95 foundation of successful physician-hospital partnerships is mutual purpose, incorporating mission, vision, values, strategies, and tactics to produce consistent clinical quality, outstanding service, financial viability, and mutual benefit; successful partnerships are characterized by true dialogue- the ability to identify what is right rather than who is right
p. 125-7 Demand-chain management is a process to attract and retain market share, not an event; collaboration will increase the size of the pie; use following steps:
- Ask what is working well?; talk to clinically respected physicians about their needs, wants, and priorities; identify referral patterns and rationale; learn their expectations of other physicians re: access, dialogue, and outcomes
- Engage service-line physicians re: hospital’s retail strategy and demand-chain management, meeting monthly to review service-line performance and share best practices
- Improve performance
- Broaden physician participation; use established service line program to improve demand-chain management in a different service line, using physicians as educators
p.143 Organizational change brings out the best and worst of every culture; fundamental indicator of organization’s ability to assimilate change is whether the organizational culture requires individual accountability for performance; 2 types of performance accountability: to patients and referring physicians and to other members of the demand chain; people must be willing to discuss performance shortfalls, share best practices, and change behavior; important to distinguish between activity and outcomes; successful demand chains never occur by chance (p. 155); accountability requires an accounting
p. 144 Questions to ask:
- Did you accomplish what you committed to?
- What barriers did you encounter?
- How soon can you accomplish the work?
p.146-50 Building a culture of accountability requires:
- Effective sponsorship: the willingness to sanction organizational change, breaking from the status quo and overcoming barriers to implementation; sponsors set performance standards and exemplify performance
- Shared purpose
- Clear performance targets, deadlines, and measurement systems to achieve short- and long-term objectives
- An effective implementation team
- A players who are not afraid to hire other A players; assisting others to improve performance; hire slow/ fire fast
Posted in Articles
Comments
Time: January 26, 2010, 12:52 am
I found your article very helpful and enlightening.Especially low or no
volume providers, with the usage of hospitalists, hospitals need to come out with very creative plans.I think in Harvard Health Plans they no longer require hospital priviledges to apply health plans.These things are changing the dynamics.
Dear Dr. Onat,
Thanks very much for making the time to comment on my blog post. You are certainly correct that the dynamics are changing often.
Best wishes





Share Your Opinions